Civilian Review

District Public Safety and Police Complaints Commissions

DPSC

37/100

Summary

Established under Police Order 2002, Arts. 38–48, with one commission per district. Composition: half elected by the Zila Council from its councillors, half appointed by the Governor from a District Selection Panel; at least one-third women; 8, 10, or 12 members depending on district size (Art. 38). Members serve three-year terms (Art. 45). Governor may remove for misconduct, criminal conviction, or three unexcused absences (Art. 46). The DPSC can direct the District Police Officer (DPO) to investigate complaints of excess, suspend accused officers pending inquiry, and direct registration of criminal cases (Art. 44(g)–(h)). It can require the DPO to submit reports within specified timeframes, giving it restricted evidence access. Discipline recommendations are advisory; the DPSC escalates to the Provincial Police Complaints Authority if the DPO fails to act. It submits half-yearly reports to government (Art. 44(b)). Actual independence is constrained because the government provides the secretariat.

Independence Scorecard

Independence Score: 37/100 (weak)
37/100
Weak
Methodology v0.1
AppointmentMixed (multi-branch)
Term length3 years
Removal standardFor cause only
Budget independenceExecutive discretion
Subpoena powerNo
Compel testimonyNo
Records accessRestricted
Public reports requiredYes
Pre-publication reviewExecutive review

Statute

Name
The Police Order, 2002
Citation
Chief Executive's Order No. 22 of 2002, Articles 38–48
Full text
Full text of law →

Jurisdiction scope

District police forces within each of Pakistan's districts; receives public complaints against police officers; investigates complaints of use of force, excess, and misconduct at the district level; can direct the District Police Officer to suspend officers pending inquiry and order FIR registration; escalates unaddressed complaints to provincial or federal authorities

Other civilian review bodies in pk