Audit

Tribunal de Cuentas de la Provincia del Chaco

TC Chaco

64/100

Summary

Drafted with AI

Drafted with AI from the cited sources under the direction of UnGovr staff. UnGovr holds editorial responsibility for this page. How this site is made

The Tribunal de Cuentas (Court of Accounts) of the Province of Chaco is the external control body of the provincial and municipal public sector and of private entities that receive state contributions (Constitution Article 178); its organic law, Ley N° 4.159, extends this to the semi-state entities (haciendas paraestatales) (Article 1). It has five members, two lawyers and three public accountants, and the presidency rotates every year (Constitution Article 177; Ley 4.159 Article 7).

The Chamber of Deputies designates the members by two thirds of its members, respecting the proportional representation of the parties and the participation of minorities (Constitution Article 177). Neither text gives a fixed term: members are irremovable while their conduct is good and are subject to political trial (juicio político) on the same grounds and by the procedure of Article 120 of the Constitution (Ley 4.159 Article 11; Constitution Article 177).

The Constitution requires the organic law to guarantee functional independence and autonomy, the power to appoint and remove its staff and the power to draft its own budget (Article 178); the Tribunal sends its draft budget to the Executive, which must send it without modification to the Chamber of Deputies for inclusion in the General Budget (Ley 4.159 Article 6).

The Tribunal can enter any body under its jurisdiction and obtain the reports and documents it considers necessary without judicial authorization, can summon provincial and municipal officials to supply information (the Governor, Ministers, heads of municipal councils and officials with immunity may answer in writing), can ask for the help of the public force, and can fine up to twice the minimum basic salary for failure to comply with its resolutions or formal notices (Article 6).

It presents its annual report (memoria) to the Chamber of Deputies before 1 March of each year and reports to the Chamber on the General Account of the fiscal year (Article 6; Constitution Article 178).

Independence Scorecard

Independence Score: 64/100 (good)
64/100
Limited
Methodology v0.1
AppointmentSupermajority legislative appointment
Term lengthNot specified
Removal standardImpeachment only
Budget independenceLegislative line item
Subpoena powerNo
Compel testimonyNo
Records accessFull access
Public reports requiredYes
Pre-publication reviewNone — reports published directly

Statute

Name
Ley N° 4.159 (Tribunal de Cuentas de la Provincia del Chaco, organic law of the Court of Accounts) and Constitución de la Provincia del Chaco (Constitution of the Province of Chaco), arts. 177 to 181
Citation
Ley N° 4.159 sancionada el 17 de mayo de 1995 (Boletín Oficial, 2 de agosto de 1995), modificada por la Ley N° 4.380 (Boletín Oficial, 15 de enero de 1997); Constitución de la Provincia del Chaco 1957-1994, arts. 120 y 177 a 181
Full text
Full text of law →

Jurisdiction scope

The provincial and municipal administration, including central, decentralised and autarchic bodies; state enterprises and companies and companies with majority state participation; and private-law entities that the State or municipalities direct, partly own, guarantee or support with concessions, privileges, subsidies or contributions (haciendas paraestatales) (Ley 4.159 Article 1). The Constitution adds private entities that receive state contributions (Article 178). Jurisdiction extends outside the Province for state and semi-state institutions that have offices there (Article 3).

Secondary Sources